Why
foreign dancers not allowed in Egypt ? It’s a couple of minutes after
two in the morning when Hanadi comes to the stage at the Haroun Al
Rashid night club in the Semiramis International. Outside, it is still
swelteringly hot and humid and the Kasr Al Aini bridge is packed with
pedestrians. Inside, the night club is packed and as the curtain goes up
on the ten-piece orchestra, palpably expectant. The setting is much as
you would expect–mirrored pillars, a low ceiling studded with tiny
spot-lights, tables corralled into long narrow holding pens of brass
railing and purple velvet padding. The audience–more women than men and
the majority of them are veiled. There is only one table, front and
center by the stage, which has no woman sitting on it.
Hanadi emerges through a side-curtain into a swirl of
tabla and I realize that it’s going to take a lot of verys to describe
her. She is very voluptuous, she is dressed in a very, very scanty
costume, and she dances very well–her hips follow the tabla while her
upper body moves to the melody of the violins. The effect is dramatic,
and not surprisingly very sensual. I drift a little, borne on the
lilting melody played out in the air by Hanadi’s long, graceful arms to
thoughts of Flaubert’s 19th century dancers and the lubricities of
Egypt. I am brought back abruptly a minute later as a nearby woman
erupts in rhythmic clapping and ululating to mark the closing of the
dance.
Their kids take up the clamor as the music fades, and
then hush up politely as the lights come up and Hanadi reaches for the
microphone. She smiles and says, good evening. Her voice is soft, and
lilts demurely as she coaxes the audience into responding. I am utterly
disoriented, the more so when I realize that her hair has been
deliberately prepared to look, and go on looking, as though she has just
stepped out of the shower.
There is some minor dispute over what this kind of
dancing is called. Popularly, it is known as belly dancing, but some
dancers prefer to call it Oriental dancing. Most people simply call it
"The Dance." Whatever you call it, it is a form synthesised of many
traditional dances and moves that have developed out of dialogue both
with Western perceptions of "the Orient," and with the commercial
imperatives of tourism.
Socially, it seems equally complex–a cultural
high-wire act in which women work their way across a complex territory,
crossing and re-crossing the line which separates the respectable from
the forbidden. It is interesting to note, that most dancers currently
dancing in Cairo’s top clubs are from outside Egypt– Hanadi being an
exception.
This, however, may be about to change. In the last
session of parliament the government introduced a labour law that seems
to be designed to upset this aspect of "the dance". As of 1st January of
the new year, foreigners will no longer be allowed to work as dancers in
Cairo.
The senior assistant food and beverage manager of the
Semiramis Intercontinental Hotel which operates Al Rashid, Ashraf Sobhi,
gives his thoughts on the ban. "The reason I believe is that there are
plenty of Russians coming into the country and you know Russian business
is not all that straight all the time and they wanted to make some
control, some rules," he says. Talking about the so-called "Russian
shows," which are commonly perceived to be the prostitution rackets.
According to an official from the Ministry of Labour,
the ban is the result of "complaints from several belly dancers and
domestics."
Other explanations abound. Personal conspiracy
theories–usually concerning the source of these "complaints"–are among
the more entertaining. But others within the industry observe that
society is becoming less tolerant and apprehensive. It may be dancers
who are being targeted now, other groups will follow later.
There is no doubt that over the years Cairo has
become the center of a world-wide resurgence in interest in Oriental
dance. One measure of this interest is in the booming business being
done by people like Mahmoud Abdel Gaafar of Khan al Khalili, who ships
more costumes abroad every year. Another is the success of people like
Hassan, a former dancer and now a teacher, in attracting foreign
students and dancers to her annual festival. But the most persuasive,
for me, is the foreign dancers who come to Cairo, either to see or to
dance, because it is seen as the world center for "The Dance." A
successful stint in Egypt can translate into a more lucrative career in
North American and European markets.
Liza El Laziza, one of Cairo’s best-known dancers,
stresses, "Cairo is the central nervous system, it’s the heart of the
form, and there are many Europeans and Westerners and Far Easterners who
come here to see the dance, but I’ve been here for four years and I’ve
actually seen the decline both in the number of the places, the venues,
where the dancers work, and a decline in the art itself."
Ban on these dancers may solve the problem of
unemployment to some extent in Egypt. But what will happen to dance as a
form of art? Will it prosper? Because any form of art, as we all know
will only grow through cross-cultural exchanges, more participation, a
broader mindset and a more liberal approach. In the name of national
interest, are we not compromising on the quality and overall growth of
something? It’s certainly a million-dollar question.