It
may sound strange, but it is a fact, that there are very few parents who
have never beaten their children, or have never thought of doing so,
howsoever deeply and dearly they may love them.
Even among the educated people, very few can control
the tendency to beat their children. As for the illiterate people, this
is the only method by which they can satisfy the curiosity of the
children, curb their feelings, get rid of their exuberance and suppress
their initiative.
When any person acts in this manner towards himself,
it is termed as ‘suicide’, and is considered a crime, but the same
behaviour towards children is described simply as thrashing and society
does not take any effective steps to check it. Only fatal injury to the
child is considered as a crime but the law does not go any further than
that. According to social workers and psychologists, there is no basic
difference between the two patterns of behaviour—suicide and thrashing
of children. Beating one’s own children is nothing but suicide, because
the reason in either case is frustration and self-contempt and the
result is also the same—the feeling of insult and masochism. Children
are beaten to punish, and suicide also is a form of punishing oneself.
In India, this problem is acute. Studies conducted
during recent years has revealed that young women do become mothers, but
mentally do not develop the qualities of motherhood. The child is
therefore badly neglected.
Often, it so happens that mothers flare up whenever
the child demands anything. They take a tight hold of the child, scold
him and shout at him. Their idea of attending to the child is not to
show love, but always to terrorise him, so that the child may always
visualise his mother with a face red with anger.
If the child refuses to eat, most mothers react as if
they have been abused. There is the case of a child whose mother would
hold her clenched fist as close as an inch from his face whenever he
cried. She would also tie a rope around his belly and tighten it.
Another woman flared up because her two-year-old
scattered about the halwa she had prepared for him with great love. This
particular woman had the peculiar habit of hitting the table with the
spoon when she was angry.
Generally, it has been found that the childhood of
such parents has been spent very badly. They did not get love
themselves, and do not give it to their children.
A psychiatric social worker says that it has been
found that such mothers, and sometimes, fathers too, have their
limitations. They do not know how to control their anger or to divert
their minds when they are angry. They do not have the capacity to get
rid of tension. Their only urge then is to beat the child. If they ask
the child to do something and he does not agree, they do not try to coax
or cajole him, because all this requires time, labour and ability. So
they resort to beating the child; this seems easier. It is not only
uneducated parents but educated ones who also beat and scold their
children. Experience has shown that parents who beat children belong to
all age groups.
There is the case of one particular woman. She was an
M. A. and had one child, two years old. She had been a very good
student. As soon as she completed her studies, she was married and the
whole pattern of her life changed. She remained idle most of the time.
Her major occupation was lying in bed and reading detective novels.
Her child was also an idler and very naughty. The
husband of the woman used to come home late because he was doing a
part-time job after office hours. She used to remain irritated and gave
vent to her anger on her husband and the child.
She used to beat the child. She knew that she was
being very harsh on the child, but still she continued to beat him. It
is also observed that when the child cried, the mother got apprehensive
because she thinks that the neighbours might get the impression that he
is being beaten. The reaction is that she beat the child all the more.
Psychologists believe that parents who beat their
children see the personality of their own mothers reflected in them.
They themselves have been deprived of love and take revenge on their
children. When the child does something they do not like, the parents
feel as if they are being neglected once again, just as they were
neglected in childhood by their parents.
A woman admitted that whenever her child cried, she
felt very bad and lost her temper. On such occasions, she felt no love
ever for her child. Another woman, who has a small daughter, cannot
stand the crying of her child. Whenever the child cries, the woman
virtually throws her down and herself goes to the other room, so that
she may have to beat her more.
There is a couple who has three children. They love
the last one, but not the other two. They beat the first two as and when
they choose.
As the children grow, their requirements also grow,
but the parents cannot fulfil them. They get irritated and beat the
children in order to conceal their weakness. This is a problem neither
for a doctor nor a lawyer, because the root cause of this problem is
social and psychological. There was a time when parents used to sell
their child or make a sacrifice of him or her. They even used to give
away the child to someone.
All this is not done today, except in rare cases. We
have become civilised, and it is the demand of civilisation that we do
not treat our children in an inhuman way. Children in our society have
generally remained neglected, and proper attention has not been paid to
their problems. It is high time now that this was done.