India
has had a rich tradition of science and technology but not as we moderns
know it. In ancient days the people of this country were more advanced
and knew more about the basic principles of science. We knew many things
about ways of life and living, which the West or the Americans of today
who did not exist just 500 years ago claim to have knowledge of. For
example, the Indians of the Vedic Age knew that turmeric powder healed
wounds and was a very effective antiseptic and that neem leaves kept
many diseases at bay. The Westerners are discovering that today and
trying to patent it in their own names. This is the east-west divide, or
the developed-underdeveloped divide or the haves or have-nots divide
that is the root cause. Having developed industrially enabling them to
manufacture and produce goods of all types in large quantities, and no
market to sell them, they turned their eyes towards underdeveloped
countries seeking profits. There are many senior citizens today who
remember that during their school days, forty odd years ago, they were
given the newly introduced Coca Cola free for several weeks.
Alongside, the multinational companies launched
massive advertising campaigns to persuade people to give up their
traditional soothing, cooling drinks and drink the synthetic products of
the west.
Luckily, there was no television and multi-channel
cable TV those days and therefore it took a long time for the message to
penetrate the Indian psyche. Then the MNCs opened up another front to
make the product popular. They built a false sense of status around it
and made it a symbol of sophistication, breeding and taste. They even
exploited the shape of the bottle and likened it to the contours of the
female body and soon everybody became an ‘addict’.
This is the story of how Coca Cola launched its
blitzkrieg against the people of this country and made millions and
millions of dollars of profit. It was only the redoubtable and
determined George Fernandes who gave them the boot and threw them out of
the country in those heady days of 1977 when the ‘opposition’ (those
days it meant all non-Congress parties) were ruling for the first time
in their political careers. The buzz word was live swadeshi and anything
that had a hint of anything foren about it became the target of
their ire. Had that government survived, things would have been
different today. The MNCs that were shunted out those days are now back,
some through the back door, and again making money in this country at
the cost of the people of this country. (Imagine in a country that was
once called the ‘land flowing with rivers of milk and honey’, in the
capital city of New Delhi right under the nose of the government of
India one has to pay fifty paise for a glass of water and rupee one to
urinate in a Shulab shauchalaya). This is the report card of this
country after fifty years of independence.
It is against this background that one has to see the
rising controversy over contamination of cold drinks that led to a
furore all over the country and reverberated in Parliament where the
elders decided to ban MNC produced cold drinks from the canteen of
Parliament House.
It all began when Sunita Narain, Chief of the Centre
for Science and Environment told a press conference that soft drinks
marketed by global giants Coke and Pepsi were tested and it was found
that all of them contained a ‘deadly pesticide cocktail’, which exceeded
European norms by around 11-70 times. But as there was no Indian law
that was being breached these manufacturers could go on making heavy
profits at the cost of the health of the nation. That these MNCs were
‘cutting costs’ to make their balance-sheets look better was indicated
when Narain said that samples picked up in the USA and tested did not
show any trace of pesticides. (In the USA and Europe there are standards
and rules under which citizens can drag companies to court for sub
standard food and drink items.
The CSE testing result indicated high individual
pesticide residues. For example, there was at least 15 times more DDT
and metabolites than acceptable. Besides, lindane content was twenty one
times higher, chlorophyrifos was 42 times and melathine 87 times more
than prescribed health norms.
Narain expressed her shock that while MNCs were not
setting an example on their own, the government was sitting back and
ignoring the need for regulatory norms. She said: "This is worst than
the bottled water case. At least mandatory certification is needed for
this but there is nothing for this food industry. Here, there are no
norms at all for an industry, which is established; it is not a question
of small players."
According to experts there is high danger content in
the pesticides found in the bottle. For example, DDT and metabolites
affect the nervous system and are probable carcinogens. Lindane is a
nerve poison that affects the reproductive system and is a known
carcinogen. Chlorophyrifos can cause pneumonia, muscle paralysis and
respiratory failure leading to death. Malathion also affects the nervous
system and continuous use can cause respiratory paralysis and death. The
cold drinks manufacturers took no time to explain the situation. The
Sunita Narain press conference had hardly ended when Coke and Pepsi,
traditional rivals all over the world, sunk their differences and joined
hands. They challenged CSE testing methods and sought an independent
scientific inquiry into the matter. At the same time they claimed that
their products were safe and world class.
The chiefs of the two companies (Sanjeev Gupta of
Coke and Rajiv Bakshi of Pepsi) stated that their companies operated
within European and American norms with ‘top grade testing and top grade
products’. They said that their companies conducted testing at every
stage regularly.
But the damage had been done. While newspaper readers
learnt the ‘shocking news’ with their morning cup of tea, pandemonium
erupted in Parliament that resulted in cold drinks being banned in the
canteen in Parliament House. While Chairman of the Catering Committee E.
Ahmed ordered immediate banning of soft drinks, other Lok Sabha members
demaded that they be banned through the country. Union Health Minister
Sushama Swaraj tried to assuage the anger of the members with the
assurance that she had already ordered a comprehensive inquiry into the
reports.
For members of the Lok Sabha, the Sunita Narain
report provided them a good stick to hammer the MNCs with. They made the
most vehement criticism against the MNCs manufacturing the tested cold
drinks and said these companies were not only looting the country but
also endangering the health of the people by selling adulterated cold
drinks.
The furore that erupted in Parliament overflowed in
to the public domain. The Kolkata Municipal Corporation’s health
department was the first to seize the bottles of soft drinks
manufactured by Coca Cola India and Pepsi Co India. Earlier, mayor
Pradeep Ghosh lead a delegation of health department officials and
raided Kwality restaurant on Park Street. Samples of bottles had been
taken for testing.
In Kerala the State Pollution Board opened up another
front by confirming the presence of carcinogens in the sludge waste the
Coca Cola was distributing free of cost to local farmers as fertilisers.
The firm’s factory in Palakkad district had been the object of
complaints that it was overdrawing groundwater and also using
contaminated groundwater. A news channel put out a report saying that
the sludge left as a by-product of its manufacturing process was
contaminated with heavy metal residues well beyond the legal limits
allowed.
In Delhi, residents seemed to be scared of imbibing
cold drinks. Sales dropped drastically and many schools removed their
cola-vending machines. One wag came up with the slogan ‘it’s a choice
between rum and coke or run or choke’. However, the story at McDonald's
was different. Sales rather zoomed because the management announced that
they did not serve bottled cold drinks at their outlets. ‘We get the
concentrate from Coke and use our own water at the vending-machines’.
Meanwhile, the cola giants got a surprise supporter
in the form of Mahant Vir Bhadra Mishra, Trustee Chairman of the Sankat
Mochan Mandir, editor-in-chief of Sanmarg, and former science
professor of Banaras Hindu University. He wanted to know where the tests
were conducted, what was the extent of the sample, from which areas or
cities were the samples taken, who were the scientists who conducted the
tests and in which laboratory the tests were conducted and what was the
methodology. He maintained that unless all these details were not
formalised the matter should not have been exploded in the media in the
way it was done.