The
BBC came under fire last week for its part in the death of a British
arms expert after confirming that he was the source of its report that
the Government had "sexed up" evidence to justify the war in Iraq.
Lawmakers of British Prime Minister Tony Blair’s Labour Party lashed
out at the national broadcaster for its conduct during a bitter
dispute over its report that the government embellished its
intelligence on Iraq’s weapons programmes.
The BBC, which had previously refused to name its
source, said it was "profoundly sorry" over the death of former U. N.
weapons inspector and defence ministry consultant David Kelly, but
stood by its decision to air the report. "We continue to believe we
were right to place Dr. Kelly’s views in the public domain," it said.
Kelly, 59, was found dead on July 18 after
apparently committing suicide following a grilling earlier in the week
from a parliamentary committee examining the accusations—hotly denied
by Blair’s office—that a key dossier last September on Iraq had
exaggerated the threat of Saddam Hussein’s arsenal.
While he denied being the primary source for the
May 29 BBC story, Kelly admitted briefing Andrew Gilligan, the BBC
defence correspondent whose report triggered the furore. Gilligan, who
has come under fire from lawmakers, said that he did not distort what
Kelly had told him. "I want to make it clear that I did not misquote
or misrepresent Dr. David Kelly," said a BBC statement issued on
behalf of Gilligan.
"Entirely separately from my meeting with him, Dr.
Kelly expressed very similar concerns about Downing Street’s
interpretation of intelligence in the dossier," the statement said.
But the chairman of the Foreign Affairs Select
Committee, which has been probing the disputed dossiers, said there
was a "fundamental conflict" between the evidence given to the
committee by Kelly and Gilligan.
"I think the BBC has got to look at itself long and
hard now after Andrew Gilligan’s latest evidence to the foreign
affairs committee," Labour M. P. Donald Anderson said.
The BBC, which prides itself for its reputation for
rigorous journalistic standards and an independent viewpoint, is no
stranger to clashes with the government.
Margaret Thatcher’s government had criticised the
broadcaster’s coverage of the Falklands War in 1982, though the BBC
stood its ground and retained the support of voters. Nevertheless, the
broadcaster’s naming of its source turned some of the glare of the
media spotlight away from Blair.
The Prime Minister, grappling with the biggest
crisis of his political career, has been dogged by the burgeoning
scandal on his trip to East Asia, even facing calls for his
resignation from within his own party.
But Blair, who has previously accused the BBC of
having committed "an attack on my integrity", adopted a more
conciliatory tone, saying he was "pleased" the broadcaster had named
Kelly as its source. "I am pleased the BBC has made this
announcement," he said in a statement following a summit with South
Korean President Roh Moo-Hyun. "Whatever the differences, no one
wanted this tragedy to happen. I know everybody including the BBC, has
been shocked by it."
"The independent Hutton inquiry has been set up. It
will establish the facts. In the meantime, our attitude should be one
of respect and restraint, no recriminations, with the Kelly family
uppermost in our minds."
Even before the BBC’s statement on Kelly, however,
allies of Blair had relaunched the war of words with the broadcaster.
Writing in The Observer, Peter Mandelson, a
former British minister close to Blair, hit out at the BBC’s
"obsession" with attacking the Prime Minister’s communications chief,
Alastair Campbell.
Gerald Kaufman, a Labour M. P. who chairs the
Commons Culture, Media and Sports Committee, meanwhile said the BBC
should be brought under the new Ofcom communications watchdog.
"The BBC has behaved deplorably and there are
serious implications for its future," he said. Meanwhile, the family
of Kelly has accused the British Prime Minister of hounding him to his
death.
Blair said last week he "absolutely" intended to
remain in office despite the crisis and ruled out a call by the leader
of the opposition Conservative Party, Iain Duncan Smith, to recall
parliament following the discovery of Kelly’s body near his
Oxfordshire home. Kelly, who had been sucked into a dispute over
whether officials in Blair’s office had hyped intelligence on Iraq to
justify war, had slashed his left wrist. His family made it clear that
it wanted someone to shoulder the blame for his despair.
"Events over recent weeks have made David’s life
intolerable and all of those involved should reflect long and hard
over that fact," they said in a statement.
Special Branch detectives from Scotland Yard have
sealed off Kelly’s Whitehall offices as part of a wide-ranging
criminal investigation into why the Ministry of Defence scientist
died.
As police continued their detailed search of the
microbiologist’s home, they said they believed nobody else was
involved in his death.
Blair, clearly stricken by news of Kelly’s death,
has urged politicians and the media to hold back from speculating
about the affair until a judicial inquiry investigates it. One of
Blair’s former junior ministers, one-time actor Glenda Jackson, has
urged him to resign. The Prime Minister told Britain’s Sky News
in an interview last week from the Japanese spa town of Hakone that
recalling the House of Commons, which rose for the summer, "would
generate more heat than light".
Last week, he ignored a British journalist who
asked at a news conference: "Have you got blood on your hands, Prime
Minister? Are you going to resign over this?" A statement issued by
Kelly’s wife, Janice, and daughters Sian, 32, and twins Rachel and
Ellen, 30, paid tribute to Kelly’s "integrity, honour and dedication".