|
Bangladesh – In Pakistan’s Footsteps
Bangladesh
was created in stormy conditions and continues to suffer stormy phases
during its 36 years of history. However, one cannot help but notice that
ever since its creation under the influence of its army it has followed
the Pakistan model of existence. Thus the uniform has emulated General
Zia-ul-Haq in the Islamization of the State and now General Musharraf in
decimating democratic institutions.
M.K Dhar
Whether by coincidence or
design, Bangladesh's military-backed interim government seems to have
chosen the disastrous path Treated by Pakistan's military rulers, Gen
Musharraf of eliminating mainstream politicians and introducing a new
system of governance that is subservient to the Army. Even though the
announcement about the next general election being held in Nov. - Dec.
2008 is welcome, the attempt to introduce Pakistan-style democracy is a
cause of concern for the entire region.
Whatever might be the alleged
crimes of the two former prime ministers, Sheikh Hasina, leader of the
Awami League, and Khaleda Zia, leader of the Bangladesh Nationalist
Party and hundreds of other politicians charged with extortion, bribery
and corruption, they all deserve a fair trial under due process of law,
with respect for their basic individual rights. The setting up of quasi
military courts to pronounce pre-determined sentences against
inconvenient politicians is itself a negation of the rule of law and
freedom of judiciary.
Such being the case, the
arrest on extortion charges of Sheikh Hasina has not come as a surprise.
Her detention and probable arrest of Khaleda Zia on charges of tax
evasion signals the start of the military-backed administrations "mines
two" plan of oust these two leading figures from politics. Unfortunately
for it, the High Court has halted the proceedings against Sheikh Hasina,
granted her bail and asked the government to explain why the action
against her should not be declared illegal. Ms Hasina has denied the
charges as "conspiratorial". A panel of Supreme Court lawyers is
fighting the legal battle on her behalf.
The military backed regime
seems to have set before itself a number of objectives. It wants the two
leaders to lose credibility with masses and bar them from future
election by manipulating their conviction by a kangaroo court. Like Gen
Musharraf, it wants to break the two mainstream parties Awani League and
Bangladesh Nationalist Party-and restructure them under the military's
guidance, or even float another outfit like the ruling PML(Qaid) in
Pakistan which is fulfilling the military's agenda. Another assumption
is that conviction of Sheikh Hasina would demoralize and disintegrate
Bangladesh's secular and pro-liberation forces as she happens to be
their unquestioned leader. Awami League secretary Abdul Jalil was forced
by the military to issue a statement dissociating himself from the
party, as well as, national politics. The irony is that Sheikh Hasina
and the Awami League are bearing the brunt of the military's wrath
although they welcomed the takeover by the Fakhruddin Ahmed-led interim
government as a "deliverance" from the BNP-laden set-up and a totally
partisan Election Commission.
Observers of the scene point
out of that Bangladesh inherited an Army that was schooled in the same
mentality as Pakistan's military. Thus, it was that Sheikh Mujib's
tenure at the helm ended in a military-sponsored blood-bath almost two
years before his old sparring partner, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was
overthrown in Pakistan and eventually executed by Gen Ziaul Haq. It was
Hossain Mohammad Ershad who offers close parallels with Zia, not least
because he went out of his way to emulate the Pakistani tyrant. He
encouraged Islamic fundamentalists, formally ending Bangladesh's status
as a secular state and even opted for a referendum along the lines
dictated by Zia in Pakistan. Unlike the latter, Ershad was overthrown by
a popular uprising and subsequently served a long sentence in prison.
The latest crisis was
fuelled in large part by the Awami League's refusal to accept the
caretaker set-up bequeathed by the outgoing government headed by Khaleda
Zia, because it was headed by a former BNP leader and the Election
Commission too was stuffed with BNP supporters who had arranged
meticulously to rig the elections in BNP's favour. It was Sheikh
Hasina's threatened boycott of the January 22, 2007 election (which were
not held) which gave a handle to the military to intervene and install
an unrepresentative caretaker administration. Currently Sheikh Hasina,
whom the army could not prevent from returning to Dhaka from abroad, is
being victimized for asking too many questions of the military
dispensation. For instance, she criticized the decision to hold
elections in late 2008 and saying this was too long a period for the
country to be without a democratically-elected government. Last week,
she did what was considered undoable in Bangladesh. She publicly accused
the Defense Intelligence Agency of meddling in politics, arresting and
torturing politicians and engaging in efforts to make or break political
parties.
Bangladesh's election
commission says more than a year is needed to revise the defective
electoral rolls and make the necessary constitutional amendments. No one
has any clue as to nature of the amendments proposed whether something
sinister is contemplated to enhance the Army's role and curtail civil
liberties. Gen Musharraf too distorted the Pakistani constitution beyond
recognition through a series of ordinances, combined the office of
President and Army Chief and got the amendments approved by a captive
parliament with the support of the Islamists to whom he handed over the
administration of two provinces- NWFP and Balochistan- and on whom has
banked for support. One wonders is the present rulers in Bangladesh too
are set to implement an Islamists agenda in order to create a
support-base for a military dispensation. This is being attempted
through elimination of the leadership of two main stream parties and
entertaining a complaint by Jaman-I-Islami, a fundamentalist outfit
which formed part of the Khaleda Zia- run coalition, accusing Sheikh
Hasina of murder. Obviously, the Islamists are waiting in the wings and
will jump in to fill the political vacuum, which may be created if the
two leading political parties are disintegrated.
Since its birth 36 years ago Bangladesh has passed
through stormy times, with prolonged spells of military rule and
democracy. Successive regimes, however failed to solve the country's
problems and fulfill the people's basic needs. It cannot survive another
prolonged spell of political uncertainty and military repression. The
task assigned to the caretaker regime is to get the electoral rolls
corrected, restructure the Election Commission with the inclusion of
independent persons, take steps to be prevent rigging and impersonation
and order free, fair and transparent elections as soon as possible in
which all parties are allowed to participate. Thereafter, power should
be handed to a civilian government, care being taken not encourage
disruptive, anti-national and fundamentalist forces. The Army should
stay where it should- in the barracks. |