In
a face-to-face interview, Dr. Balram Jakhar,a former Krishi Pandit,
a living participant in India’s Green Revolution and a lead- ing
representative of the farmers in Indian politics who commanded great
respect and competence in some of the top elective positions,
including that of the Speaker of the Lok Sabha, expressed his
anguish and agony at the cruel drought being faced by the Indian
farmer. He expressed his dismay at the callous and cold-hearted
attitude of the political and bureaucratic bosses at the plight of
the farmer in India. But he also expressed his firm faith and
determination that the Indian farmers will continue their struggle
for a better tomorrow and a prosperous India, as they had done in
the past in the face of man-made hurdles and natural catastrophes.
Dr. Balram Jakhar pointed a
finger at all concerned and said: "For the last seven years, nothing
has been done for the farmers and no steps taken to ensure that the
country is ready to face drought and famine when it comes. They (the
Government) have even delayed their decision to identify and declare
the drought stricken divisions in the country."
He posed a question to all
national leaders and the so-called agricultural policy experts and
planners. "Why were we not thinking far ahead? Why have we suddenly
woken up and started thinking and talking of drought now? We should
have already thought out and decided what steps we can take in a
contingency."
With pain in his voice, Dr.
Jakhar said: "The soybean crop has been damaged, the bajra crop has
been ruined and paddy has been destroyed in Punjab and Haryana.
Within the next five or 10 days, the worst is going to happen. The
monsoon will come or not come. The forecasts will remain confusing.
So that is what it is all about. We cannot always depend upon such
prophesies about rain and food."
When asked to comment on
whether the subsidies promised and often provided to the farmer by
the Government were of any help in motivating the farmer and solving
his problems and hardship to some extent, Dr. Jakhar replied in
anger: "It is not the Government which is subsidising the farmer.
The reality is that it is the farmer who is subsidising the
Government and the nation."
The DayAfter
wanted to know whether the Government, which claimed to have an
Agriculture Policy, really had a holistic Farmers Policy? In his
usually spirited way, he recalled: "We had a policy. I started it. I
gave the policy. It was discussed in Parliament. In fact, it was
first discussed with the chief ministers before it was brought to
Parliament for discussion. It has been trimmed, distorted and
rehashed. I do not know why they are doing this."
In response to Sunil Dang’s
clincher: "Since 1942, when the great Bengal famine had hit the
country, why did we not think of planning and implementing a
well-thought out and effective ‘Drought Policy’, he asserted: "I did
start it. The Watershed Programme was the first step towards it; we
worked out a water policy, a water conservation policy, a plantation
policy, a granary policy. We wanted to tell all concerned about the
danger of the subsoil water receding if our water resources were not
well identified, well conserved and well maintained. The water table
has gone more than 50 feet deeper this year. If we go on callously
like we are today, there may be no water at all. That is if we
insist on not taking up the Watershed Programme."
Sunil Dang reminded him that
to face such drought conditions and emergencies, the late Rajiv
Gandhi had mooted a National Water Mission, which had involved
eminent scientists, leading national science laboratories and a
cross-section of water and agriculture experts. What happened to
their recommendations? He said in visible dismay: "Nothing has been
done. Nothing has been done in the last seven years". A ticklish
issue came up. Why was there no consensus among political parties
and no co-ordination between the Centre and the States and farmers
organisations on agriculture which was the prime need, lifeline and
mainstay of the Indian nation?
He said: "Seventy five per
cent of Indians live in the villages and one way or another, they
are all connected with agriculture. That is where the real India
lives, Gandhi ji said. To which Nehru added, everything else can
wait but not agriculture. Rajiv Gandhi gave an agriculture strategy
and said that implementing it was the most important thing to do.
That is what I also think is the most important thing. Even as a
Speaker, though I was not supposed to take part in discussions, I
always did take part when there was a discussion on agriculture. And
that must be the top priority, whether it is this government or that
government. Whether there is one government in a State and another
in the Centre. This top priority and national policy must cut across
all party lines. We have to bear the brunt of what is going to
happen, all together..."
Jakhar pointed to some farm
realities which should make anyone sit up in shame and dismay. He
said: "Do you know that Rs. 50,000 crore worth of agricultural
products perish because the farmers have no facility of processing
them and protecting them? In developed countries abroad, almost 40
to 45 per cent of this perishable agricultural product is processed,
packaged and sold. But here it is different. We manage to process
and package only 1.8 per cent of our perishable agricultural
products. In the Eighth Plan, there was a provision of just Rs. 24
crore for horticulture. But I fought and got an allocation of Rs.
1,000 crore for it. How could I get so much allocation? Because I
understood its implication and importance and was able to convince
my colleagues in the Government and the Planning Commission. We have
to diversify agriculture. We have to not merely change the pattern
of paddy and cash crop cultivation but we have to compete with the
world agriculture market forces too. We must place agro-based
industries in our villages where the farmers can be employed and
their product put to optimum and competitive marketing in the
national and international markets.
"The Government must realise
that agriculture is the most important thing in our lives. Roti
hi sab se bari baat hai...Have you read Kabir? He said Na
kuch dekha naam dharam men, naa kuch dekha pothi men, Kahat Kabir,
suno bhai sadho, jokuch dekha roti men....
When The Dayafter asked
Jakhar that considering the drought emergency that India faced,
considering the cruel challenge faced by the Indian farmer, and he
himself being one of the affected farmers, whether he had an
Emergency Plan to meet the looming catastrophe, he said: "We will
not let the country starve. There is always planning. We know how
things can be done. We have a food plan, we have a storage plan and
we know what to do when there is a contingency. That is what we are
here for. And that is why God had given us a mind and a plough. If
we cannot meet the challenges and if we cannot see beyond our nose
then what the hell are we here for?... He said the Indian farmer had
the will and the guts to stand up for himself. We need the
Government, but if the Government does not care, we can take up with
this Government too. Policy should be in the hands of those who are
conducive to the agricultural sector. We should not be
neglected...." Of course, he was voicing the sentiment of the
majority of Indian farmers.
When it was put to him that
most political parties, including his own, had managed to turn
agriculture into a pawn of urban politics, he said: "I know it. But
there is nothing as consistent as a will to change. And I think, we,
the farmers, have the will and we shall make politicians and the
people realise that the importance of the farmer cannot be neglected
any more. We can look for ourselves, they must look and care for us,
and we shall make them understand this. This country needs real
farmers to represent them, not just a book farmer or a minister. We
need those who are the sons of the soil who have gone through the
agony and anguish which is the lot of the Indian farmer. Those who
know it and feel it. His feet should be right on the ground whether
the weather is hot or cold." Finally, Jakhar was asked to name at
least half a dozen political leaders all around the country whom he
could call good farmers also? He said: "That is the problem. There
is not one whom I can honestly call a good farmer among the
political leaders...."